Skip to content

Face
Face
Eyes
Eyes
- Eyes Cosmetics
  
  Eyes Cosmetics
  
  Mascara
  Eyeliner
  Eyebrow
  Lash Serum & Primer
  Eye Primer
  Eyeshadow
  Discontinued or Limited Edition
- Eye Care
  
  Eye Care
  
  Eye Creams
  Eye Treatment
  Eye Masks
  Discontinued or Limited Edition
- Tools & Accessories
  
  Tools & Accessories
  
  Eye Brushes
  Tweezers
  Eyelash Curlers
  Discontinued or Limited Edition
Lips
Lips
- Lip Cosmetics
  
  Lip Cosmetics
  
  Lip Liner
  Lipstick
  Liquid Lipstick
  Lip Gloss
  Lip Balm
  Lip Tint
  Discontinued or Limited Edition
- Lip Care
  
  Lip Care
  
  Lip Primer
  Lip Scrubs
  Lip Balms
  Lip Sets
- Accessories
  
  Accessories
  
  Lip Brushes
Bath & Body
Bath & Body
- Bath & Shower Gels
  
  Bath & Shower Gels
  
  Body Wash & Shower Gels
  Scrubs
  Hand Soap
  Hand Sanitizer
  Body Lotion
  Hand & Foot Lotion
  Manicure & Pedicure
  Discontinued or Limited Edition
- Fragrances
  
  Fragrances
  
  Women Fragrances
  Perfumes
  Travel Sprays
  Body Mists
  Men Fragrances
  Cologne
  Discontinued or Limited Edition
- Sun Care
  
  Sun Care
  
  Sunscreen
  After Sun Care
Brands
Brands
- Mary Kay
  
  Mary Kay
  
  Makeup
  Skincare
  Bath & Body
  Fragrances
- the CRÈME shop
  
  the CRÈME shop
  
  Skincare
  Makeup
  Collabs
- Younique
  
  Younique
  
  Eyes
  Lips
  Cheeks
  Brushes & Applicators
Exclusives
Exclusives

Facebook
Instagram

Search our site

Face
Makeup

Foundation
Concealer
Color Correcting
Bronzer & Contour
Highlighter
Blush
Face Primer
Setting Spray & Powder
Makeup Samples
Discontinued or Limited Edition

Skincare

TimeWise Skincare
TimeWise Repair
Face Wash & Cleansers
Face Cloths
Toners
Makeup Remover
Day Creams
Night Creams
Face Mists & Oils
Men's Skincare
Skincare Sets
Travel & Deluxe Size Skincare
Skincare Samples
Discontinued or Limited Edition

Masks

Face Sheets
Face Masks
Discontinued or Limited Edition

Treatments

Face Serums
Acne Treatment
Dark Spots
Facial Peels
Exfoliators
Discontinued or Limited Edition

Accessories

Face Brushes
Brush Replacement Heads
Travel Bags
Compacts
Blotters
Discontinued or Limited Edition
Eyes
Eyes Cosmetics

Mascara
Eyeliner
Eyebrow
Lash Serum & Primer
Eye Primer
Eyeshadow
Discontinued or Limited Edition

Eye Care

Eye Creams
Eye Treatment
Eye Masks
Discontinued or Limited Edition

Tools & Accessories

Eye Brushes
Tweezers
Eyelash Curlers
Discontinued or Limited Edition
Eye Collection
Discover everything you need for captivating eyes, from shadows to liners & more!
Lips
Lip Cosmetics

Lip Liner
Lipstick
Liquid Lipstick
Lip Gloss
Lip Balm
Lip Tint
Discontinued or Limited Edition

Lip Care

Lip Primer
Lip Scrubs
Lip Balms
Lip Sets

Accessories

Lip Brushes
Lip COllection
Explore the ultimate in lip care and color now!

Bath & Body
Bath & Shower Gels

Body Wash & Shower Gels
Scrubs
Hand Soap
Hand Sanitizer
Body Lotion
Hand & Foot Lotion
Manicure & Pedicure
Discontinued or Limited Edition

Fragrances

Women Fragrances
Perfumes
Travel Sprays
Body Mists
Men Fragrances
Cologne
Discontinued or Limited Edition

Sun Care

Sunscreen
After Sun Care
Bath & Body Collection
Indulge in our collection of bath and body essentials!
Brands
Mary Kay

Makeup
Skincare
Bath & Body
Fragrances

the CRÈME shop

Skincare
Makeup
Collabs

Younique

Eyes
Lips
Cheeks
Brushes & Applicators
Exclusives

Search our site

Cart

Cart

Eyes

Collection: Eyes

Mascara
Eyeliner
Eyebrow
Lash Serum & Primer
Eye Primer
Eyeshadow
Eye Palettes

This collection is available to our Pink Choices members only.

Membership is Free!

Create an account and log in to view this page.

Login

or

Create an Account

Sort by

Featured
Most relevant
Best selling
Alphabetically, A-Z
Alphabetically, Z-A
Price, low to high
Price, high to low
Date, old to new
Date, new to old

Filter and sort Filter

Filter and sort

Filter

90 products

Brand

Anastasia Beverly Hills (1)
Benefit Cosmetics (2)
Lancôme (2)
Laura Mercier (2)
Mary Kay (60)
NARS (4)
NYX Professional Makeup (3)
Smashbox (3)
Too Faced (4)
Younique (9)

Clear

Price

From $

To $

Skin Type

All Skin Types (15)
All (6)
Mature Skin (1)

Clear

Concern

Anti-Aging (3)
Dark Undereye Circles (2)
Puffiness (2)
Dependent on Product (2)

Clear

Form

Creme to Powder (1)
Liquid (9)
Lotion / Cream (2)
Loose Powder (3)
Pressed Powder (17)
Gel (3)
Pencil (4)
Mechanical Pencil (2)
Cream (7)
Stick (2)
Lotion (1)
Crayon (1)

Clear

Coverage

Buildable (6)

Clear

Size

Full Size (34)
Travel Size (1)
Sample (3)
Standard (24)

Clear

Collection

BENEFIT BAD GAL BANG! (2)
Brow Definer Pencil (1)
Eye Shadow (1)
Eyeliner (1)
LANCOME MONSIEUR BIG VOLUME MASCARA (1)
LANCOME ULTRA-PRECISE FELT TIP WATERPROOF LIQUID EYELINER (1)
Loose Eye Shadow (3)
Primer (2)
Timewise (2)
Timewise Repair (1)
Too Faced Better Than Sex (2)
ULTIMATE MASCARA (1)
YOUNIQUE MOODSTRUCK (1)
YOUNIQUE MOODSTRUCK PRECISION DIP & DRAW (1)

Clear

Availability

In stock (84)
Out of stock (27)

Clear

Sort by

Clear

90 products

NYX Pro Angled Eyeliner Brush

Vendor:
NYX Professional Makeup
NYX Pro Angled Eyeliner Brush

Regular price

$7.50

Regular price

~~$10.00~~
Sale price

$7.50

Add to cart

Quick view
NYX Ultimate Edit ~ Ultimate Utopia Eyeshadow Palette

Vendor:
NYX Professional Makeup
NYX Ultimate Edit ~ Ultimate Utopia Eyeshadow Palette

Regular price

$9.00

Regular price

~~$9.00~~
Sale price

$9.00

Add to cart

Quick view
Smashbox Always Sharp Waterproof Kohl Liner ~ Penny Lane

Vendor:
Smashbox
Smashbox Always Sharp Waterproof Kohl Liner ~ Penny Lane

Regular price

$20.25

Regular price

~~$27.00~~
Sale price

$20.25

Add to cart

Quick view
Younique Eye Lash Curler

Vendor:
Younique
Younique Eye Lash Curler

Regular price

$15.75

Regular price

~~$21.00~~
Sale price

$15.75

Add to cart

Quick view
Younique Quadra 4-in-1 ~ Serum * Primer * Tubing * Mascara ~ Black

Vendor:
Younique
Younique Quadra 4-in-1 ~ Serum * Primer * Tubing * Mascara ~ Black

Regular price

$38.50

Regular price

~~$55.00~~
Sale price

$38.50

Add to cart

Quick view
Mary Kay Lush Hues Eye Color Trio (Discontinued/Vintage)

Vendor:
Mary Kay
BRUSHED SUEDES PRECIOUS METALS
Mary Kay Lush Hues Eye Color Trio (Discontinued/Vintage)

Regular price

$8.99 $11.95

Regular price

~~$0.00~~
Sale price

$8.99 $11.95

Choose options

Quick view
Younique Eyeliner Pencil ~ Perfect

Vendor:
Younique
Younique Eyeliner Pencil ~ Perfect

Regular price

$13.50

Regular price

~~$18.00~~
Sale price

$13.50

Add to cart

Quick view
Mary Kay Mini Mineral Eye Color Quad (Discontinued)

Vendor:
Mary Kay
Mary Kay Mini Mineral Eye Color Quad (Discontinued)

Regular price

$12.00

Regular price

~~$0.00~~
Sale price

$12.00

Add to cart

Quick view
Mary Kay At Play Eyeshadow Trio Compact (Discontinued)

Vendor:
Mary Kay
Mary Kay At Play Eyeshadow Trio Compact (Discontinued)

Regular price

From $9.99

Regular price

~~$10.00~~
Sale price

From $9.99

Choose options

Quick view
Mary Kay At Play Dual Tip Eye Shadow (Discontinued)

Vendor:
Mary Kay
Mary Kay At Play Dual Tip Eye Shadow (Discontinued)

Regular price

$12.00 $15.50

Regular price

~~$10.00~~
Sale price

$12.00 $15.50

Choose options

Quick view
Mary Kay Fluid Eye Color ~ Rainforest (Discontinued)

Vendor:
Mary Kay
Mary Kay Fluid Eye Color ~ Rainforest (Discontinued)

Regular price

$7.50

Regular price

~~$15.00~~
Sale price

$7.50

Add to cart

Quick view
Mary Kay Loose Eye Shadow ~ Lilac Lace (Discontinued)

Vendor:
Mary Kay
Mary Kay Loose Eye Shadow ~ Lilac Lace (Discontinued)

Regular price

$9.75

Regular price

~~$0.00~~
Sale price

$9.75

Add to cart

Quick view
Mary Kay Loose Eye Shadow ~ Cashmere (Discontinued)

Vendor:
Mary Kay
Mary Kay Loose Eye Shadow ~ Cashmere (Discontinued)

Regular price

$9.75

Regular price

Sale price

$9.75

Add to cart

Quick view
Mary Kay At Play Bold Fluid Eyeliner (Discontinued)

Vendor:
Mary Kay
BLUE MY MIND GOLD METAL HELLO VIOLET REAL TEAL
Mary Kay At Play Bold Fluid Eyeliner (Discontinued)

Regular price

$9.75

Regular price

~~$10.00~~
Sale price

$9.75

Choose options

Quick view
Mary Kay All-Over Eye Shadow Brush

Vendor:
Mary Kay
Mary Kay All-Over Eye Shadow Brush

Regular price

$9.00

Regular price

~~$12.00~~
Sale price

$9.00

Add to cart

Quick view
Mary Kay Eye Crease Brush

Vendor:
Mary Kay
Mary Kay Eye Crease Brush

Regular price

$9.00

Regular price

~~$12.00~~
Sale price

$9.00

Add to cart

Quick view

‹ Prev
1
…
3
4
5
6
Next ›

Customer Service Hours: Mon - Fri: 9am - 4pm PST Contact Us: ContactUs@pinkchoices.com Selling Your Inventory: BeautyBuyback@pinkchoices.com

Shop

Contact Us
Search
Beauty Buyback

Disclaimer

We are not affiliated with, nor endorsed by Mary Kay Inc. Any names, logos or trademarks are used only to accurately describe the product being sold and not meant to imply affiliation. Any of our products do not come with the original manufacturer's guarantee.

Exclusive benefits

Enter email here

Apply for our free membership to receive exclusive deals, news, and events.

Facebook
Instagram
Follow us on social media!

© 2004 - 2026, Pink Choices. All rights reserved.

Site designed by FDG Web
Refund policy
Privacy policy
Terms of service
Shipping policy
Contact information

Country/region

Country/region

United States (USD $)
Australia (AUD $)
Switzerland (CHF CHF)

Payment methods

Menu

Search

Cart

Choosing a selection results in a full page refresh.